My wife used an article like this on me once. Had I known at the time she was checking off a list, there would have been a statement along the lines of, "Don't peg me with generalities."
What is a clear indication to one may be a proverbial red herring to another. Before judging your guy's commitment level by a column from a well-meaning site or magazine, remember that God gave you a brain and a heart to judge for yourself.
The following observations are here to assist you, your instincts and your common sense. Read them, and then forget them and judge your relationship with Brandon on its own merits.
(His name is not Brandon? Brandon is better than Bubba or Bruce, so let's just call him Brandon.)
Here are a few indications Brandon may be struggling with commitment.
Does it feel like he is avoiding something?
When Brandon introduces you to people in his life — or even the waiter at the restaurant — does he stutter? This is my … (Friend, Backgammon partner, parole officer ... ?) If he can't call you his girlfriend, you probably aren't.
He is unable to split his focus
He tells you that if he splits his focus the world will end. "I have to focus on college … or work … or my mother," he says. Poor guy. He probably can't chew gum and text either.
Was he hatched?
You know Brandon has a family because he complains that his little brother is always asking him for money or to borrow his car. But whenever a family member calls he lets it go to message. Also, he says his sense of humor runs in the family — so they have to be around somewhere.
He won't let you see his phone
His cell is always locked and pass-worded. If he does give in to your pleadings to take a look, you have to do it right there in front of him, and the pass code is changed within hours.
He doesn't introduce you to women in his life
It is perfectly logical that there would be other females he knows. Surely you are not the first Brandon has ever had a relationship of some sort with. However, if he is tight-lipped about having spoken with an ex-girlfriend last week — and you know he has — chances are you are not running in first place in his heart or his mind.
Next week is a world away and he can't even think about it — let alone pencil you in. "Things will change and it's such a hassle," he says. He is a short-term planner. Committing now means he can't back out if something "better" comes up.
He is all about the grand gesture
But he forgets about the smaller, less spectacular things — like holding your hand or opening the door for you. It is true that he could just be, as he explains it, "oblivious to others," or "an only child," or "thinking about something else." But if he isn't doing the little things it is likely because he doesn't see the need.
He is either all or nothing
It's a big group activity with a limousine and a fancy dinner, or it is hanging out at your place. There is little in-between. His everyday happenings don't include you. Shopping, getting the car washed, talking about his doctor appointments — you aren't a partner in that sense of the word.
He still flirts with others
His demeanor doesn't change with other girls — as in, he is still flirting. This may indicate that he doesn't believe he has found "the on" and is keeping his options open, or that he is clueless. You may need to have a talk with him.
He doesn't ask for your advice
Or, if he does, he just lets you talk and then changes the subject. Discussions don't get too deep with him. He is simply not going to appear vulnerable or raise any questions about his mode de ser in front of you.
Having commitment issues isn't the relationship killer that you may have been led to believe. There are many guys who come across as Joe-no-commitment that are dedicated and devout men, committing to women and families, and taking on responsibilities that would bowl a single guy over.
Maybe Brandon just needs proper motivation. If you are willing to commit, you might consider giving him a reason to as well.